Eire: the 2024 European Parliament elections – rise of the independents? – Nexus Vista

Eire will maintain its European Parliament election on 7 June alongside native elections. Rory Costello writes that the emergence of immigration as an election challenge has led to a fall in assist for Sinn Féin, whereas unbiased candidates look set to obtain a big share of the vote.


This text is a part of a sequence on the 2024 European Parliament elections. The EUROPP weblog may even be co-hosting a panel dialogue on the elections at LSE on 6 June.


Firstly of this yr, it regarded as if this European election would ship a powerful victory for the left-wing nationalist social gathering Sinn Féin (a member of the GUE group). Election forecasts predicted they might win 4 of Eire’s 14 seats within the European Parliament, greater than every other social gathering.

Sinn Féin had already achieved their best-ever outcome within the final common election in 2020, forcing conventional rivals Fianna Fáil and Fantastic Gael right into a coalition authorities (together with the Greens) for the primary time. This gave Sinn Féin a platform because the chief of the opposition from which it may additional enhance its assist, and it capitalised on widespread dissatisfaction with the federal government in addressing Eire’s extreme housing scarcity.

The emergence of immigration as an election challenge

In current months, nevertheless, Sinn Féin has skilled a pointy decline in assist, in response to polls. It’s a well-known story: assist for the principle left-wing social gathering drains away amongst working class voters when immigration turns into politicised. Paradoxically, the housing disaster that had pushed voters to Sinn Féin initially additionally made it simpler for far-right events and activists to make immigration a salient challenge.

Eire has one of many quickest rising populations within the EU, principally pushed by immigration. Whereas a lot of this immigration is for employment and schooling, there has additionally been a big enhance within the variety of refugees and asylum seekers coming to Eire (Eire has obtained round 100,000 Ukrainian refugees since 2022 and there was a 75% enhance in worldwide safety candidates this yr).

Far-right activists have been concerned in organising protests across the nation in opposition to asylum seekers. There have been anti-immigrant riots in Dublin final November, and dozens of arson assaults on properties designated for housing asylum seekers. All of this has pushed the difficulty of immigration excessive up on the political agenda.

Plenty of far-right events have emerged in Eire lately, however to-date none has had any electoral success. It appears unlikely that any of those events will win a seat on this European election, regardless of the rising salience of the difficulty of immigration.

The reason being that voters who’re motivated by opposition to immigration seem like drawn extra to unbiased (i.e. non-party) candidates who’ve expressed considerations about immigration than to the much less palatable far-right events. A few of these unbiased candidates are in with an opportunity of profitable a seat, however total, the anti-immigration vote is sort of dispersed amongst numerous rival candidates, which can scale back its impression.

A fragmented political panorama

With Sinn Féin dropping floor, the political panorama in Eire appears extraordinarily fragmented. Opinion polls specializing in the European Parliament election recommend that the three largest events – Sinn Féin, Fantastic Gael (EPP), and Fianna Fáil (Renew Europe) – are every supported by roughly 20% of the voters. The same share of voters assist unbiased candidates (of assorted hues), whereas the remaining vote is cut up amongst a number of small events together with the Inexperienced Celebration, the Labour Celebration, the Social Democrats and numerous far-left and far-right events.

The Inexperienced Celebration are at the moment the third member of the federal government coalition, and as so typically occurs to junior coalition companions, they’ve misplaced vital assist throughout their time in authorities. The Inexperienced Celebration achieved their best-ever election outcome within the 2019 European Parliament election, however they’re anticipated to lose at the very least considered one of their two seats this day trip.

One of the notable options of Irish politics proper now’s the energy of independents. Independents have all the time been a function of Irish politics, facilitated by the permissive electoral system, and independents have historically finished effectively in European Parliament elections. What’s hanging about current polling is that independents as a bunch entice as a lot or extra assist than the most important political social gathering. This speaks to an anti-party and anti-politics temper amongst Irish voters. Three of Eire’s present MEPs are independents, and this might doubtlessly enhance on this election.

European and native points

Like many member states, European Parliament elections have often been handled as second-order nationwide elections in Eire. The truth that they’re held concurrently with elections for native councils reinforces the tendency for home points to dominate. Additionally, the pro-EU consensus among the many fundamental political events and the general public (confirmed by the latest Eurobarometer survey) diminishes the extent to which battle over Europe options within the marketing campaign.

There are indicators, nevertheless, that points with a European dimension are actually starting to occupy a much bigger place on the agenda in European election campaigns than beforehand. The controversial EU migration pact, on which Eire has the suitable to opt-in or out, has featured prominently in lots of the election debates. So too have environmental and agricultural points such because the Nature Restoration Legislation and the Nitrates Directive (for which Eire has a derogation).

The EU’s place on the Israel-Hamas conflict has additionally featured within the marketing campaign, though on this challenge there’s a broad consensus among the many events that the EU ought to take a more durable line on Israel. Nevertheless, these points have a tendency to not be the issues that voters are elevating on the doorsteps as candidates marketing campaign across the nation. Maybe giving the European Parliament election its personal date within the calendar, with out lumping it in with native elections, is important for voters to really deal with it as a European slightly than home contest.


Observe: This text provides the views of the writer, not the place of EUROPP – European Politics and Coverage or the London Faculty of Economics. Featured picture credit score: Alexandros Michailidis / Shutterstock.com


Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *